Trade Deadline Outlook: St. Louis Cardinals

The Cardinals reached the All-Star break in a tricky position.  With about 40% of their season remaining, they’re only 1.5 games back in the Wild Card and have a real shot at the playoffs.  That’s the case despite an offseason in which they did not attempt to improve the club, in what longtime president of baseball operations John Mozeliak termed a “reset.”  And Mozeliak will be navigating the July 31st deadline as a lame duck, given the club’s stated plan to give his job to Chaim Bloom for the 2026 season.

Mozeliak put it this way nine days ago (Katie Woo of The Athletic reporting): “I do feel like where we are in the week leading up, or the 72 hours leading up to the trading deadline, may affect how we make our decisions.”  He further explained, “When we talk about all-in, I do think based on where the franchise is, based on payroll down and thinking more of the long view, we’re still trying to balance today’s success with ultimately having long-term success.”

Record: 51-46 (28.5% playoff probability, per FanGraphs)

Buy Mode

Potential needs: Right-handed bat, pitching depth

Regarding the transition to Bloom, Mozeliak said, “When we get closer to the deadline, if there’s something that could impact how the future looks, clearly we’ll take a look at in a more collaborative sense.”

With relative stability on the pitching staff, Mozeliak’s deadline focus on the buy side may be on an offense that ranks fifth in the National League with 4.58 runs scored per game.  Within that respectable showing, however, is a team that ranks 10th in the NL with an 88 wRC+ against left-handed pitching.

Mozeliak acknowledged the deficiency but also said, “I do feel like where they’re going to be in a week or two is not a glaring hole in terms of trading deadline thoughts,” given Ivan Herrera‘s July 13th activation and minor injuries affecting other righty bats like Nolan Arenado and Willson Contreras.

Brendan Donovan has been an everyday player, generally at second base, despite consistent struggles against southpaws over the last three seasons.  Alec Burleson, currently deployed in the corner outfield, has been similar.  Center fielder Victor Scott II has sat against some lefties in the last month in favor of Garrett Hampson.  Lars Nootbaar, on the IL for a left costochondral sprain, had been sitting here or there against lefties but often with Donovan or Burleson in his spot and Thomas Saggese getting the start at second base.

Given that Mozeliak said “I don’t think we’re ever going to take away from the guys we’re trying to see play,” it may be difficult to find the ideal addition.  An improvement over Hampson as Scott’s platoon partner could be one answer.  Perhaps a call to the White Sox regarding Austin Slater or Michael A. Taylor of the White Sox would make sense.  A homecoming for Randal Grichuk could work, though he hasn’t played much center in recent years.  Maybe the Astros will find Chas McCormick expendable once he completes his rehab assignment for an oblique strain.